I don’t know what it is about Island Man that has intrigued me so. Perhaps it’s the blue color? Perhaps it’s the clash of the green tub against the blue label? Perhaps it’s a soap hobby where I just want to smell the next thing. At any rate I picked up this tub from Hoosier knowing the Stirling performance would be good. The scent is pretty decent. It’s a great mid-road scent that’ll fit right in the middle of the bell curve. I can’t see many who would find the scent off putting nor does it inspire my imagination. It’s just a good solid manly soap that has mass appeal. I’d rate it a C+.