(08-22-2020, 11:21 AM)DanLaw Wrote: (08-22-2020, 05:23 AM)Oasisdave Wrote: (08-20-2020, 08:54 PM)DanLaw Wrote: OMFG!! Is this the real Pink Floyd with Waters or the fake one solo act with Gilmour? Haha Scent profile?
Actually, as don't see a giant penis tagged on the pig, will take it Waters Pink Floyd
OK so I've seen 'Pink Floyd' led by Gilmour 4x times and Waters touring 3x and the legit Floyd Wall tour back in the day and every single show has been AMAZING. There's no guitarist that puts emotion into playing guitar like Gilmour and Waters presentation of the Floyd songs adds something that the Gilmour presentation is missing.
I for one am grateful I appreciate both!!
Would never suggest Gilmour less than brilliant guitarist and gilder of songs but the heart of Pink Floyd was the core songwriting, album conceptualization and tour imagineering. Waters was the heart. To believe otherwise is to accept that A Momentary Lapse of Reason and the albums that followed are equal to the albums spanning from A Saucerful of Secrets thru The Final Cut and that adding a penis to pig balloon makes it one’s artistic creation. Waters, like Barrett is/was quite insane but it makes him no less the heart of what outside UK is/was known as Pink Floyd and that he came to hate the fellow members of the band (and his fans) does nothing to marginalize his creative achievement as the leader/heart of the band.
Who is Pink Floyd? Did they open for Jonny Cash? Just kidding. As a guitarist myself love Gilmore playing and waters writing is on point.