What's your favorite soap by PAA?

Yes, nice selection but I don't get the excitement. The one's I tried really were just average soaps at best.

I just bought 1k from them. I haven't tried it yet, you know what? I'll use that one for later.

I'm just a little put off by the gimmicky sales man-ish descriptions but I did hear a several good remarks about their products.

I can't speak to earlier versions of the soap, but the latest iteration performs very well for me. Also, I've gifted a few pucks (CaD mostly) to new wet shavers, and all have reported success and enjoyment.

Douglas is da man!!! I love me some Cad and Tombstone!!! Got the Beachguy and a bunch o others in my kingsized shave den. Douglas never lets me down and his soaps and aftershaves hit BigPoppas sweet spot!!! Hooyeah!!!

Didnt that guy ..... nevermind

Yes, nice selection but I don't get the excitement. The one's I tried really were just average soaps at best.

I haven't tried their soaps yet. But overtime I think of it I can't decide because there is too many scents and V2, 2.5, 3...I'm just not sure. They should make maybe 6 awesome scents and stick with it.

Yes, nice selection but I don't get the excitement. The one's I tried really were just average soaps at best.

I haven't tried their soaps yet. But overtime I think of it I can't decide because there is too many scents and V2, 2.5, 3...I'm just not sure. They should make maybe 6 awesome scents and stick with it.

Agreed. Their scent selection is a little overwhelming.

In my collection, ranked by my favorite scent first:

1.) Speakeasy - Classic. Easily my favorite. I used this one in rotation with Stirling's Ozark Mountain on my Honeymoon, if that tells you anything. It's nothing like Ozark, btw. It's got a floral top, but the amber/wood finish is quite delicious to me.
2.) CAD - What can I say? Pairs super nice with Fine's American Blend.
3.) Steeplechase Green - This is an old HTGAM tin. The scent here is not a dead ringer for Polo Green, but unique enough that it makes a regular appearance.

The performance is't quite as good as Stirling to me, I'll always have a special place for them. But it's perhaps up there in terms of organic ingredients and...non-tallow. Fat makes everything better. Douglas, if you're reading this, make a tallow soap and I'll be the first at the register, just to see what you do.

CaD and ClubGuy are pretty good.

Aloha Smackdown. Fun scent, nothing else like it in the den.

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk