Let's make it tougher, Top Soap Brand

I cannot participate in this thread as I consider MdC and B&M both to be my favorite soap.  I have however decided to order a couple other brands based on this topic .......

Don't leave us hanging wingdo. What'd you order Doug?

SharpSpine At the moment I have the two Caties, several PAA soaps, a Tiki bar, a sapone de paolo and if I can settle on a couple scents I am going to give Stirling a try.

I ordered several of the PAA and I will probably do the same with Stirling.  The scents I love I will keep, the rest will make their way to BST.

I think you'll like Stirling. Nothing has outperformed it for me.

CRSW for me.
Full disclosure: I have yet to try B&M or PannaCrema

CRSW is all I would need if I had any self control.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

While I am not a fan of CRSW's scents overall, the original Vetiver (I hink it may be back) is an awesome vetiver.

B&M. Outstanding performance in each of their soap bases, and the most interesting scents. Don't like interesting? Will's got straight forward scents covered, too.
The variety of B&M (in both soap bases and scents) is what broke the tie with MLS. Surprised MLS didn't get a mention here. Especially with the introduction of their latest soap base and alcohol splashes in all scents. But even their previous soap base was great.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

While I am not a fan of CRSW's scents overall, the original Vetiver (I hink it may be back) is an awesome vetiver.

Are you referring to the Vetiver Moderne? If you like that scent you might love a fragrance by Atelier Cologne. Vetiver Fatal it is called. Have you tried it? It has a similar mix of vetiver and plum.

My three neck and neck faves are Soap Commander, Stirling and Reef Point. If I had to pick one it would be Soap Commander

While I am not a fan of CRSW's scents overall, the original Vetiver (I hink it may be back) is an awesome vetiver.

Are you referring to the Vetiver Moderne? If you like that scent you might love a fragrance by Atelier Cologne. Vetiver Fatal it is called. Have you tried it? It has a similar mix of vetiver and plum.

No, I am referring to the original "Vetiver". I don't care for either of the Moderne scents. My Catie's Bubbles arrived this morning and I will be giving one of them a spin today.

I would choose B&M for the variety and complex scents, matched with outstanding performance.

Ah ok wingdo, I am not familiar with the original.