Favorite Tallow Soaps?

From today's soaps a would pick the following without any particular order

Tabac
Haslinger
MWF
Cella
Czech and Speake
D.R.Harris
Dimitri's
Palmolive
Monsavon

I appreciate how quickly a vegan soap can lather, and sometimes I crave that "clean slick" feeling, but nothing beats the creaminess of tallow. Tops for me right now:

Barrister & Mann
Tabac
CRSW
D.R. Harris

Though reading through this thread I now have Reef Point and some Mickey Lee samples in a cart online... dangerous...

You should give Stirling a try sometime too.

I have not tried a large selection of soaps in the year or so I have been at this. But I have to say that the best soaps I have tried are Tabac, TFS Tobacco Verde, Cella, and two soaps that were recently gifted to me. RR Mudder Focker and B&M Fireside. The Fireside scent is as intoxicating as Stirlings Ozark Mountains.

The Fireside scent is as intoxicating as Stirlings Ozark Mountains.

Completely agree... I pick up scents like burnt toffee with the oak and cedar undertones and the richness of the cognac that just make this soap.

I have not tried a large selection of soaps in the year or so I have been at this. But I have to say that the best soaps I have tried are Tabac, TFS Tobacco Verde, Cella, and two soaps that were recently gifted to me. RR Mudder Focker and B&M Fireside. The Fireside scent is as intoxicating as Stirlings Ozark Mountains.

I haven't tried Fireside yet but I had a sample of Ozark Mountain and plan to buy the full size this weekend. That's a great scent. Do you not consider Stirling one of the best too?

Mystic Water
Mike's Natural
Tabac
Valobra
Palmolive
Cella

* Mystic Water
* Mike's
* Shannon's
* Cold River
* Haslinger

I didn't think there were tallow soaps other than Barrister and Mann

Alongside yours I like Stirling and Mike's and Reef Point.

MWF
Stirling
Mike's
MW
B&M

My favorite tallow soap is, hands down, Barrister & Mann.