favorite bay rum products

Beer Soap Brewing Company's Bay Rum

This soap smells EXACTLY like gummy coke bottle candy. Delicious.

While thats not quite the smell I look for in a bay rum it just goes to show that there is something for everybody in bay rum.

Have you tried the Wickham's Club Cola soap - it smells like (surprise) cola! If thats a scent you like then there's one to add to your list, its not rum but you can add it to rum with a twist of lime and its ok.

https://topofthechain.ca/product/shaving...ving-soap/

VERY interested. Especially since I gave up all soda 11 years ago. Good price too. How's the performance?

Came back to the Gilbert Henry this morning and found that I both liked the scent and the refreshing feel of the splash. It's on deck for tomorrow's shave as well.

Beer Soap Brewing Company's Bay Rum

This soap smells EXACTLY like gummy coke bottle candy. Delicious.

While thats not quite the smell I look for in a bay rum it just goes to show that there is something for everybody in bay rum.

Have you tried the Wickham's Club Cola soap - it smells like (surprise) cola!  If thats a scent you like then there's one to add to your list, its not rum but you can add it to rum with a twist of lime and its ok.

https://topofthechain.ca/product/shaving...ving-soap/

VERY interested. Especially since I gave up all soda 11 years ago. Good price too. How's the performance?

I think you'll need to solicit feedback from someone who has tried Wickham recently because they may have updated the formula. The tub I got was a few years back when they were calling it Super Smooth - it was a smaller diameter tub that resembled a cream cheese container with a snap on lid. The scent was great but I don't recall the performance as being memorable. To be fair, that was a few years back and my experience and technique have improved a lot since then - I'm finding that products that didn't perform well for me in the past now miraculously do. Go figure. In any case, I'll dig into my box of unloved products to see if I can find the Wickham and see if its improved with time

Will do sir. Thanks for the info.

Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum A/S
Route 66 "Rum Runner" soap. While there is no bay in "Rum Runner" I still consider it a Bay Rum product

If any of you bay rum lovers missed churchilllafemme 's recent post in his Fragrance Terms thread you'll find it close to the bottom of this page:

https://damnfineshave.com/thread-fragran...#pid179268

This is an excellent thread well worth subscribing to so you never miss an instalment.

My favourites are, in order:
Derby City
PAA Atom Age
Providence Perfume
Dominica

All wonderful but all variants on a theme

My favourites are, in order:
Derby City
PAA Atom Age
Providence Perfume
Dominica

All wonderful but all variants on a theme

I've not tried Derby City or Providence Perfume but now I'm curious.

Seems all Churchlllafemme’s posts are worth tagging

Probably in some kind of order:

• St John's Bay Rum
  
• Pinaud Clubman Virgin Islands Bay Rum
  
• Ogallala Bay Rum