#11
I think you may have just sold me on the Rocca.  It is a beautiful razor from the looks of it.

DiggaDog and ExtraProtein like this post
#12

Geezer
New Brunswick, Canada
I doubt I could really tell the difference between Astra SP and Astra SS in a blind shave test, but for some reason I prefer the SPs.
Both give good performance for the price, and the SPs were my go-to blades until I discovered Shaverboy blades.
I once hyper-miled an Astra SP to 100 shaves, but really I should've quit at 80 or so.

ExtraProtein and Matsilainen like this post
We could be Heroes, just for one day.
- David Bowie -
#13

Super Moderator
San Diego, Cal., USA
I use both the Astra SP and the Astra SS and what I use is just what I'm in the mood for.  To me, they are very close in sharpness, comfort, etc.  I have others that I like as much or better like the recently discovered (for me) Tiger Platinum.  Unless a blade just doesn't agree with me for some reason, I am quite happy to use it.  Blades I am not fond of such as Zorrik, Dorco, and Feather I just don't bother using.  The Astra SS, though, happily remains in my rotation.

AlanH81, Matsilainen, Rebus Knebus and 1 others like this post
#14

Member
Chicago Suburbs
(11-28-2020, 03:36 PM)MoneyForNothin Wrote: I had good experience with Nacet as well, but i think Astra Stainless edged out as the winner

It depends upon your preferences for sharpness and smoothness. Astra SS has a great balance of sharpness and smothness. Nacets are a little sharper, but not quite as smooth.

Matsilainen, ExtraProtein and MoneyForNothin like this post
#15
So I got a few shaves under my belt with the Astra Stainless. They're okay. I still prefer the Platinum blades. The stainless blades were definitely smoother, but I think my face is just accustomed to the Platinum blades. I got some minor razor burn on my neck line and nicks from the stainless blades which surprised me. This isn't an issue I typically have. Overall a decent blade, but not better than the Platinum Astra's for me.

Sent from my 2PZC5 using Tapatalk

Rebus Knebus, ExtraProtein and Matsilainen like this post
#16

Member
Gatineau, QC, Canada
Yup Tiger Platinum is My Choice no irritation smooth shave & use em 3 times and dispose em.

Also Tatra is a same company smooth and just as Tiger Platinum Performance. 

I’m glad I discover them by Jim Will Shave on YouTube 

Alan H

Matsilainen and ExtraProtein like this post
"Strive not to be a success, but rather to be of value."

  - Albert Einstein
#17
LOve this blade in just about any razor.

Matsilainen and ExtraProtein like this post
#18

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
It’s better than 90% of the blades out there.

Hard to go wrong when you can score 100 of them for $7 shipped on Amazon

Dave in KY, Matsilainen and ExtraProtein like this post
#19

Member
Chicago Suburbs
(12-11-2020, 01:48 AM)txiab Wrote: So I got a few shaves under my belt with the Astra Stainless. They're okay. I still prefer the Platinum blades. The stainless blades were definitely smoother, but I think my face is just accustomed to the Platinum blades. I got some minor razor burn on my neck line and nicks from the stainless blades which surprised me. This isn't an issue I typically have. Overall a decent blade, but not better than the Platinum Astra's for me.

Sent from my 2PZC5 using Tapatalk

It sounds like the Astra SP blades are sharp enough for you and you do not need/want the sharper edge of the SS blades. Also, it depends on the razor. I can only use Astra SP blades in a very aggressive razor where a SS blade would be too sharp. But in a moderately aggressive razor Astra SS blades are perfect for me, which Astra SP blades are not sharp enough.

Just keep the SS blades in the back of the drawer. As you age, you may find that you beard gets a lot tougher. Once your beard turns grey and then white, the ASP blade may no longer be your preferred blade. It does not happen to everyone. There are plenty of senior citizens whose beard never became coarse, but I also know plenty whose beards are like steel wool and very sharp blades are needed to get the job done.

Matsilainen and ExtraProtein like this post
#20

Member
New Zealand
(This post was last modified: 12-14-2020, 08:32 PM by DiggaDog.)
[/quote]

It sounds like the Astra SP blades are sharp enough for you and you do not need/want the sharper edge of the SS blades. Also, it depends on the razor. I can only use Astra SP blades in a very aggressive razor where a SS blade would be too sharp. But in a moderately aggressive razor Astra SS blades are perfect for me, which Astra SP blades are not sharp enough.

Just keep the SS blades in the back of the drawer. As you age, you may find that you beard gets a lot tougher. Once your beard turns grey and then white, the ASP blade may no longer be your preferred blade. It does not happen to everyone. There are plenty of senior citizens whose beard never became coarse, but I also know plenty whose beards are like steel wool and very sharp blades are needed to get the job done.
[/quote]

Very wise words.
I've spun around the Sun 73 times now and my taste in razors/blades has altered from years ago.
Tech and Super Speed for years then the Timeless .68 OC stainless razor.
Now the stainless Karve #F, and #G plates are my 'go to'.
Not because my technique has improved that much, but I find I now need the more aggressive razor and sharper blade.
The Karve #G with a Feather is a sweet shaver.

Captainjonny, Matsilainen and ExtraProtein like this post


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)