(This post was last modified: 05-27-2016, 05:51 AM by oMniPotent.)
+1 Stirling.
I used to be a fan of Nivea Sensitive ASB but not really anymore. It is probably the most hyped balm there is but I tend to air on the side of more natural these days and no so mass produced, but that's just me. One that isn't mentioned much in any forums is Simpsons balm. Very short list of ingredients, most of which are nice. More of a balm where as Nivea ASB is basically a milk.
If you have sensitive skin, fragrance is another major thing you want to avoid, and if I recall Nivea Sensitive has fragrance in the ingredients list, but again, people swear by it.