#981

Member
Illinois
(11-24-2021, 04:33 PM)Stubble Daddy Wrote: [Image: 7b90cb67f3b4da2f0df86ba9c2555dd1.jpg]

Razor: Razorock Lupo .72
Brush: Trotter Handcrafts - “Burnt Butterscotch” w/ 26mm G5C
Soap: Eufros - Sirio
Aftershave: Floid - Black
Blade: Nacet

Another G5C shave. Trying to figure out if I “like” it. It’s a bit of a strange knot… allow me to break this down in a pros & cons list.

G5C Pros:

- Looks awesome. Semi-realistic Badger appearance. Best looking Synth IMO (when dry).
- Super soft tips and hair
- Price is lower than the other G5 knots (but is this really a G5? It’s not really that similar to the other G5’s… marketing move perhaps?)
- Small Glue Bump
- Works great if you smash it into your face while lathering. lol

G5C Cons:

- Black dye came out on the first 2 lathers
- Once wet, the hair fibers sorta stick together and the knot looks and feels small. Like a 24mm knot.
- On the calipers, none of the 4 knots I purchased were 26mm. All 4 were ~25.2mm.
- Too much springy backbone, no real splay… even when set at 53mm. Maybe I should try setting it even higher?

So it’s a mixed bag for me at this point.

Thanks for reading.
PT

[Image: 5d9b14baee8f48d03601ca1ec97ccc83.jpg]
[Image: ff9c1e514be2718f5561373f04a31a80.jpg]
[Image: d1d21df0fd1aac5e13380de3919b1346.jpg]
[Image: c40b1d72ea2b70741c380196fd1226e3.jpg]
[Image: 65e371741a14cfb88cfca8bb33c73c59.jpg]
[Image: a27f7b33d5c77ccfb58d7903c190f61f.jpg]

Great review Paul... When do you suppose you will re-set the knot? I'd like to know if there is enough free loft to set one at around 57-58mm as that is what I have my 3 TurnNShave knots set at and enjoy them very much. Thanks.

HighSpeed, Old Sarge, Stubble Daddy and 1 others like this post
#982

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
(11-25-2021, 03:50 PM)muzichead Wrote:
(11-24-2021, 04:33 PM)Stubble Daddy Wrote: [Image: 7b90cb67f3b4da2f0df86ba9c2555dd1.jpg]

Razor: Razorock Lupo .72
Brush: Trotter Handcrafts - “Burnt Butterscotch” w/ 26mm G5C
Soap: Eufros - Sirio
Aftershave: Floid - Black
Blade: Nacet

Another G5C shave. Trying to figure out if I “like” it. It’s a bit of a strange knot… allow me to break this down in a pros & cons list.

G5C Pros:

- Looks awesome. Semi-realistic Badger appearance. Best looking Synth IMO (when dry).
- Super soft tips and hair
- Price is lower than the other G5 knots (but is this really a G5? It’s not really that similar to the other G5’s… marketing move perhaps?)
- Small Glue Bump
- Works great if you smash it into your face while lathering. lol

G5C Cons:

- Black dye came out on the first 2 lathers
- Once wet, the hair fibers sorta stick together and the knot looks and feels small. Like a 24mm knot.
- On the calipers, none of the 4 knots I purchased were 26mm. All 4 were ~25.2mm.
- Too much springy backbone, no real splay… even when set at 53mm. Maybe I should try setting it even higher?

So it’s a mixed bag for me at this point.

Thanks for reading.
PT

[Image: 5d9b14baee8f48d03601ca1ec97ccc83.jpg]
[Image: ff9c1e514be2718f5561373f04a31a80.jpg]
[Image: d1d21df0fd1aac5e13380de3919b1346.jpg]
[Image: c40b1d72ea2b70741c380196fd1226e3.jpg]
[Image: 65e371741a14cfb88cfca8bb33c73c59.jpg]
[Image: a27f7b33d5c77ccfb58d7903c190f61f.jpg]

Great review Paul... When do you suppose you will re-set the knot? I'd like to know if there is enough free loft to set one at around 57-58mm as that is what I have my 3 TurnNShave knots set at and enjoy them very much. Thanks.

I re-set it today and test again tomorrow. I’ll post my thoughts here tomorrow afternoon.

Thanks 
PT

HighSpeed, MaineYooper, MilkCrate and 1 others like this post
#983

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
[Image: bbcfc4f085426bb30ac7da6b4484cac9.jpg]

Razor: Rex Envoy
Brush: Brad Sears Arley 28mm
Soap: MWF
Aftershave: Fine - Fresh Vetiver
Blade: Personna Super

Happy Thanksgiving to each of you. Enjoy your Family and eat delicious food!

All the best,
Paul

Dave in KY, MilkCrate, Matsilainen and 3 others like this post
#984
Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!

Old Sarge and Stubble Daddy like this post
-Tim

-Another satisfied Fluffy Industries customer - V2 Mini Copper.
-Proud member of Club Oscuro - Trotter Handcrafts Costa Oscuro.
#985

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
Well, I went to raise the G5C up to 57mm and it just won’t work… at least not well.

When I bring it up to that height you can easily see the knot base. not much side wall support there either.

I’m not convinced that raising up super high would help much anyways.

If you are testing this knot, I’d recommend trying a loft of 55mm.

[Image: ed6648f9e6407240cdb72003ee13d2cd.jpg]
[Image: 24859d26add172b0d7c4f81f554f6b6b.jpg]

Dave in KY, MaineYooper, HighSpeed and 6 others like this post
#986

Member
New York
It's like the caliper is laughing at you (lols).

muzichead, Old Sarge, MaineYooper and 4 others like this post
#987

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
(11-25-2021, 11:50 PM)mrdoug Wrote: It's like the caliper is laughing at you (lols).

Nice catch Paul!

“LOLS”… what are the odds?!

Matsilainen, Old Sarge, MaineYooper and 3 others like this post
#988

Member
gone to Carolina in my mind
What a bummer. I'm sorry the knot reset didn't work out Paul. What's your judgement on whether putting it back to 53mm and breaking it in some more might help?

Stubble Daddy and Old Sarge like this post
Technique Trumps Tools
Skin Care Trumps Skin Repair

Be Cool, be Kind, and be Well
--  Mike --
#989

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
(11-26-2021, 04:47 AM)HighSpeed Wrote: What a bummer.  I'm sorry the knot reset didn't work out Paul.  What's your judgement on whether putting it back to 53mm and breaking it in some more might help?

Hey Mike. Yes, I’ll re-set this guy at 55mm when I get time. I highly doubt it will make a noticeable difference compared to 53mm, but hey, I’ll keep at it.

Matsilainen, HighSpeed, mrdoug and 1 others like this post
#990

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
[Image: 4ae395c00b01cb676020194c3c5190bc.jpg]

Razor: Blackland Blackbird w/ TiBam Titanium Handle
Brush: Chisel & Hound w/ 26mm Fanchurian Knot
Soap: McDuff’s - Old Strathcona
Aftershave: McDuff’s - Crowsnest Pass
Blade: Perma-Sharp

MaineYooper, Dave in KY, Marty M and 5 others like this post


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)