Soaps you've hated this year

Since Saponificio Varesino is the hot topic — I’ve had a few shaves with Felce Aromatica and the 70th Anniversary Special Edition. I enjoy both scents very much, and I really like how the lather feels on my face. But I, too, have noticed that the lather isn’t as slick as the lather many other soaps produce. And post-shave isn’t the greatest, either. I do enjoy how the scent from the 70th Anniversary soap seems to stick around for quite a while. Not many soaps do that for me.

Can't say I "hated" SV (Colonia). The scent was nice. PIF'd it.

I have a box where I put my unloved soaps, aftershaves and balms.  Generally any product whose quality or scent can't justify its use.  I plan to do something with the box at some point, likely PIF it - on the one hand I feel bad passing on my rejects but YMMV as they say.  Who knows?  The stuff might find love after all, everyone can find someone at last call.  Included in this box are such soaps as Sudsy Soapery - virtually unscented, OSP, again no scent to speak of, CRSW too mildly scented, there are a few that were once good performers but they've been outclassed by some of the new formulations on the market - they didn't get worse but the competition got better so into the box of no love they go.

add Caties Bubbles to the not a fan of list, i just think i'm a tallow guy, Soap Commander is the only non tallow soap i still use

I have an "excess" shave stuff drawer in the laundry room for the unloved/unused items (I faintly hear the tune "Island of Misfit Toys," from the Rudolph Christmas TV special!). I find it has non-tallow soaps that just didn't work for me. And as Marko said above, I feel a little bad about trying to sell or PIF them. But hey, maybe they will be stars for someone else.  I am waiting to see if someone else who can't tolerate scented soaps asks about fragrance free ones, and then I planned to help out! As mdv39 noted, I also find Soap Commander's soaps to be great non tallow soaps.