(06-04-2024, 03:06 AM)ErkRusselReserve Wrote: After reviewing your ratings I was surprised to see your Polsilver rating so low. I have a two tucks of 2016 Pols and they have been fantastic. They were so good that I picked up an entire sleeve of Wizamets (2022). Unfortunately, that have been very middling for me. According to folks on B&B something changed with Wizamets in June 2020 and they haven't been the same since.
Hmm, maybe I need to do a face to face showdown. The 2022 Wizamets for me have been shaving at the $8/100 level, not a premium blade at all. I don't foresee picking up anymore Pols, as they are $1+ per blade, too premium for this face!
The Polsilvers I had were purchased om around 2017, but I do not know when they were manufactured. Every time I have tried to use them, I have found them to be sharper than Astra SP, but not as sharp as Gillette Silver Blue and Gillette Platinum. They are similar in sharpness to 7 O'Clock SharpEdge yellows, but the SharpEdge blades are much smoother.
The Wizamets I tested were purchased in the fall of 2023. I found them to be significantly sharper and smoother than the older Polsilver blades. That did surprise me as I expected them to be more similar. I am not a fan of Polsilver for my beard and skin, but I liked the Wizamets enough to add more blades to my collection.
BTW: The Refined Shave website is no longer online, but the testing they did on Polsilver blades several years ago was similar to my results.
Many people love Polsilver blades. I am not one of them, but if they work for you, that is great.