Name the top four, and ONLY four!

The best hard puck shaving soap you can buy, the top two are easy, what else is there?

1. Vintage Williams
2. Arko
3.
4.

The best hard puck shaving soap you can buy, the top two are easy, what else is there?

1. Vintage Williams
2. Arko
3.
4.

Tallow tabac? Like Williams it's no longer made that way, but it's still plentiful in the wild (probably more so than Williams, as they just switched to vegan the past few years). A polarizing scent, but the performance is top notch.

In that same vein, vintage Fine soaps also fit in that group. I'm very partial to their Lavender Por Homme scent, but I'm guessing the base is great in all varieties

Sent from my Pixel 4a using Tapatalk

I’ll put Tabac at #1. I haven’t tried Arko so I can’t comment. I’d put the iColoniali mango in there.  I don’t know what else. There’s several decent hard pucks but not many great ones.

How about some SV?

I like the Godrej puck, especially in a vintage-style scuttle. One of the cheapest shave soaps in the world.



Pity it's so hard to come by in Canada.
I'd have to go to Amazon (over-priced) or Maggard's (across the border).

Interesting, never heard of that one, thanks!

The scent of Godrej is a bit weird. It reminds me of "Snap" - that heavy-duty hand cleaner with pumice, which smells something like anise.
It may not be for everybody.

How about some SV?

Too pricey for me, I'm cheap!

Art of Shaving tallow
Tabac tallow
Fine tallow
DR Harris

How about some SV?

Too pricey for me, I'm cheap!

much respect!