Most Popular/Selling Shaving Soap Maker?

A lot of votes for B&M here. It is one of very few I have not tried yet. I have so many other great soaps, current production and vintage, someone please tell me what I'm missing with this one.

A lot of votes for B&M here. It is one of very few I have not tried yet. I have so many other great soaps, current production and vintage, someone please tell me what I'm missing with this one.

Well, it is a great performer. As are most of the soaps people have mentioned in this thread. The difference with the B&M ( to me) is that it's a lot easier/faster to lather at the cost of greater rate of consumption. A trade off I am more than happy to make. Stirling takes a little more work, but is well worth the effort.

A lot of votes for B&M here. It is one of very few I have not tried yet. I have so many other great soaps, current production and vintage, someone please tell me what I'm missing with this one.

I think it's borderline blasphemy in wet-shaving to not try B&M. lol. Just kidding of course, but it's definitely a must try brand. Find a scent that interests you and give it a try.

My favorite was PannaCrema when he made several fragrances, that started out in the little cardboard boxes. I'm really disappointed that as of now, OSP Obsessive Soap Perfectionist and Strop Shoppe have both gone out of business. Their soaps were brilliant.

GroomingDept is becoming increasingly popular!

A lot of votes for B&M here. It is one of very few I have not tried yet. I have so many other great soaps, current production and vintage, someone please tell me what I'm missing with this one.

I think it's borderline blasphemy in wet-shaving to not try B&M. lol. Just kidding of course, but it's definitely a must try brand. Find a scent that interests you and give it a try.

I used a whole tub from start to finish. It was a tallow/sea butter/lanolin combination if I remember correctly. It was good, but no better or worse than most of the others out there.

A lot of votes for B&M here. It is one of very few I have not tried yet. I have so many other great soaps, current production and vintage, someone please tell me what I'm missing with this one.

I think you may be missing one of the top performing soaps with top tier scent and scent creativity. If I were to make a suggestion for what to try from the B&M catalogue , I'd say you couldn't really go wrong whatever you picked but definitely one of their permanent line would likely please you - Leviathan, Bay Rum, Chesire, Seville. Of those, Leviathan is the one that I've heard the most comments along the lines of "I didn't like this (scent) the first time I used it but its since become one of my favourites." That was also my own experience with it. I'm also a bay rum fan and B&M's bay rum has a unique twist to it so while definitely a bay rum, its unlike any other one out there. Love that one.

If you do get around to giving a B&M soap a try, please let us know your thoughts.

Cheers,
Marko

Sorry. I am too busy finding the letters on my keyboard to get involved in taking a shave soap census.

A lot of votes for B&M here. It is one of very few I have not tried yet. I have so many other great soaps, current production and vintage, someone please tell me what I'm missing with this one.

I think it's borderline blasphemy in wet-shaving to not try B&M. lol. Just kidding of course, but it's definitely a must try brand. Find a scent that interests you and give it a try.

I used a whole tub from start to finish.  It was a tallow/sea butter/lanolin combination if I remember correctly.  It was good, but no better or worse than most of the others out there.

There are plenty of soaps available with top tier performance. However, if one is interested in fine scents then B&M is a must try. I know which soaps will deliver the performance I expect when shaving, which means I can simply shop based on scent these days.