Help choosing my next aftershave balm?

Hands down ABC - all great but Apricot Hull just ever so slightly better. However, have found a mixture of ETHOS Skin Food with Replenish serves very very well for all but worst winter days for my terrible skin. But if strictly balm, ABC having tried them all

Love the Kiehl's Post-Shave Repair Gel. Would like to try La Toja. 

Hands down ABC - all great but Apricot Hull just ever so slightly better.  However, have found a mixture of ETHOS Skin Food with Replenish serves very very well for all but worst winter days for my terrible skin.  But if strictly balm, ABC having tried them all

Curious to get your input.

How does PAA's Mysterium Serum compare to ABC Apricot?

With all respect, as actually favour many of their bay rum AS, it doesn't in my experience; not even remotely close  Completely different product  Last thing my skin needs is menthol, would simply kill it. 

This is a competitor for the ETHOS Skin Food/Replenish mix referenced where it isn't really up to ETHOS' standard, again not close. But for those with great skin, it is a good product at a good price

For those of us with actual damaged and sensative skin, the difference between good products and top of the line becomes readily and immediately apparent.  Unfortunately, as Frank is oft to state, quality ingredients are expensive.  Like most things in life, one gets what one pays for (and deluding self if thinking otherwise); the trick is to assure actually getting quality ingredients versus marketing hyperbole.  ETHOS simply delivers like no other line on the market at the moment. 

For a rare these days balm finisher, ABC still the king