Dragonsbeard I'll give you my choices, and why.
1. Tonka Bean - Super versatile scent, you can use it year round, extra goodness from the tonka bean butter. My #2 ETHOS scent after Dragonsbeard.
2. Lost Souls - Although I have not smelled this one, the description sounds like something I might like.
3. Vanilla Safi - If you love vanilla, this is as good as it gets. Thing is, I think most people can only take so much vanilla. I bought a 1oz when it was offered almost two years ago. I immediately bought a 7oz jar. I'm still working on the 1oz because you only need a little soap and I get tired of vanilla after a couple of days.
4. King of the North - I bought it, used it a couple of times and now it's in someone else's den. I don't like any cooling effect from anything except my air conditioner or a dip in the lake on a hot summer day.