Cinnamon Scented Soap

TFS has Mandarino e Spezie (which is red hots candy meets Christmas).  TFS also has Cannella Arancio , which is straight up red hots to my nose.  

Actually TFS Mandarino e Spezie  and Cannella Arancio are not produced anymore. However, TFS has the  Farinik soap, which is also scented with mandarin and spices (cinnamon is the predominant note).

Catie's Bubbles Le Piment de la Vie. It burned the heck out of my face, but maybe you'll have better luck.

If you're willing to consider creams, Stone Cottage Soapworks has a couple of cinnamon-dominated scents. In terms of performance it's one of my favorites, but the scents tend to be on the sweet side for me.

The "Suede de Kashmir" contains enough cinnamon to give me a very mild burn. "Spiced Myrrh" is a milder scent with (for me) no burn.

You can get 5 samples for $10.

Ginger's Garden has Cinnamon essential oil on their scent list, so it should be orderable as shave soap.

+1 on the above soap/cream suggestions. If you are interested in matching that to a cinnamon fragrance, check out Boucheron Jaipur (read up on it in Basenotes or Fragrantica).

I love the TFS Farinik soap, but if your wife is anything like mine then don't show her the jar lid as it might influence her impression, it is not very feminine looking. Great soap though.

As others have said, it might be wise to try to get samples if possible first as many people react differently to cinnamon in personal grooming products.

Please let us know how you make out with your search.

Mondial (Tcheon Fung Sing) - Mandarino e Spezie (Mandarin and Spice) is my favorite. This is supposedly the same as the above mentioned TFS Farinik soap.

I forget if B&M Nocturne has cinnamon in it but it is a warm and sweet scent which I really enjoy.

Careful with cinnamon and clove. A lot of people react to them.

Tabula Rasa Cinnamon is FANTASTIC !

Dapper dragon doesn't make the Cinnamon bun anymore which is a shame because I enjoy it.

Try Catie's bubbles Pomander it smells like Strop shoppe Russian tea.