As I said in the soap thread, I have a bottle of Shulton Old Spice that I love, and this is very close. The Shulton comes on a little softer than the Stirling to my nose, but otherwise, a fantastic homage.
Just got it back in, my best most favorite AS splash... Proraso (green) Eucalyptus & Menthol. I'm stoked with it - like the newb that I'm not. (Lol) I love this stuff.