I don’t have a huge wealth of experience - but I second the opinions above. The Muramasa is mild yet efficient. I tend to leave it on 3 as a daily driver then up to 5 if I went a few days without shaving. The only competition I have yet to find is the konsul.
If you like higher than “average” blade feel it may not be for you. That being said, on 5 there is still some blade feel, it’s just not pronounced.
As an aside, I have found its bead blasted finish to be a rock solid grip. It doesn’t bite your fingers like a clean, deep knurling, but I have extreme confidence in it. I don’t think the dimples do anything - I think it’s simply a matter of the satin finish.
Tatara also does other nice things: there is a plastic sleeve inside the inkwell stand to keep the handle from getting scratched. I don’t have this in my two other inkwell stands.
Longevity wise - I know there is an o ring inside of the mechanism, and that it is a bit finicky (Tatara apparently sent out upgrades to earlier batches consisting of a new o ring). In many years I’m sure that will rot/crack and fail. It’s a standard size. Hopefully by then you will be able to Google its size on some random forums and order a replacement (if not directly from Tatara).
I love my muramasa. It and the konsul are turning into my rotation.
DanLaw and
ewk like this post