Someone gave me a $50 Amazon card to blow.

Done. Wholly Kaw, Oleo, and a stick of Tabac.

All great soaps. Which scents did you go with?

Done.  Wholly Kaw, Oleo, and a stick of Tabac.

All great soaps. Which scents did you go with?

Shiloh and Man from Mayfair. Some here said shiloh is to sugary and artificial, but if I can handle TOBS grapefruit I think I'll be OK.

MfM has....anise (I think). Not one of my favorite scents. It isn't dominant, but it's there to my nose. The soap base is REALLY good though. I can see why people like WK. The Shiloh from Oleo arrived today. I don't think it is as, "Cloying," as some here do, but it reminds me of something I already have and I can't put my finger on it. Haven't used it yet so no comment on the soap itself.

MfM has....anise (I think).  Not one of my favorite scents.  It isn't dominant, but it's there to my nose.  The soap base is REALLY good though.  I can see why people like WK.  The Shiloh from Oleo arrived today.  I don't think it is as, "Cloying," as some here do, but it reminds me of something I already have and I can't put my finger on it.  Haven't used it yet so no comment on the soap itself.

It reminds me of Chiseled Face Santa Paula

Can you send it back?

MfM has....anise (I think). Not one of my favorite scents. It isn't dominant, but it's there to my nose. The soap base is REALLY good though. I can see why people like WK. The Shiloh from Oleo arrived today. I don't think it is as, "Cloying," as some here do, but it reminds me of something I already have and I can't put my finger on it. Haven't used it yet so no comment on the soap itself.

Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk

MfM has....anise (I think).  Not one of my favorite scents.  It isn't dominant, but it's there to my nose.

Strange how we smell things. MFM smelled like absolutely nothing to me - I did not get any scent what so ever. Perhaps it was a dud?

MfM has....anise (I think).  Not one of my favorite scents.  It isn't dominant, but it's there to my nose.

Strange how we smell things. MFM smelled like absolutely nothing to me - I did not get any scent what so ever. Perhaps it was a dud?

It isn't super strong, but I would give mine a 6 out of 10 strength wise. It has scent for sure lol

Can you send it back?

MfM has....anise (I think).  Not one of my favorite scents.  It isn't dominant, but it's there to my nose.  The soap base is REALLY good though.  I can see why people like WK.  The Shiloh from Oleo arrived today.  I don't think it is as, "Cloying," as some here do, but it reminds me of something I already have and I can't put my finger on it.  Haven't used it yet so no comment on the soap itself.

Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk

Ha, I see what you did there lol. I wouldn't send it back though. The scent of anise is there to me, but it is blended with others that make it usable for me without sending it back. YOU'RE NEXT buddy. That's a promise from me.

I would give the shiloh a 7 out of 10 strength wise. Strong lemon is all I can smell though. I can't pick up much else, but there is something there in the background. Both soaps work for me so far scent wise and I wouldn't BST/PIF them based on scent. I haven't tried the Oleo yet though so there's always that. The WK I am keeping for sure. The post shave felt really good on that one a couple of hours later.

Can you send it back?

MfM has....anise (I think).  Not one of my favorite scents.  It isn't dominant, but it's there to my nose.  The soap base is REALLY good though.  I can see why people like WK.  The Shiloh from Oleo arrived today.  I don't think it is as, "Cloying," as some here do, but it reminds me of something I already have and I can't put my finger on it.  Haven't used it yet so no comment on the soap itself.

Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk

Ha, I see what you did there lol. I wouldn't send it back though. The scent of anise is there to me, but it is blended with others that make it usable for me without sending it back. YOU'RE NEXT buddy. That's a promise from me.

I may have misinterpreted that you didn't like because of the anise.

Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk