#111

Just Here for the Shaves
Williamsburg, KY
(09-04-2024, 07:42 PM)SinCityAg Wrote: Next time I want to go after another rookie like me.  Cutty Sharp reviews were amazing.  I feel like George Selkirk with a lot less talent.  I am bringing to bat my Oliblade, Merkur 34C, and a Schick Krona for comparison.  I am also going to dust off my thesaurus to at hopefully at least find unique adjectives to dazzle you with.  

Big Grin

[Image: TSSLn3b.gif]

ewk, dtownvino, Dragonsbeard and 2 others like this post
This post by Dave in KY mentions views and opinions expressed and makes it known that they are "those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of DFS or any other member, agency, organization, employer or company."  Big Grin
#112
(This post was last modified: 09-04-2024, 09:03 PM by Cutty Sharp. Edited 2 times in total.)
(09-04-2024, 07:42 PM)SinCityAg Wrote: Next time I want to go after another rookie like me.  Cutty Sharp reviews were amazing.  I feel like George Selkirk with a lot less talent.  I am bringing to bat my Oliblade, Merkur 34C, and a Schick Krona for comparison.  I am also going to dust off my thesaurus to at hopefully at least find unique adjectives to dazzle you with.  

Big Grin

Too funny.

I've been doing a lot of razor and blade testing this year in an effort to sell off the collection and decrease clutter. So although I now have less razors, the downside is I have more words and opinions!

SinCityAg, Dragonsbeard and cigarman like this post
#113
(This post was last modified: 09-04-2024, 10:04 PM by Cutty Sharp. Edited 4 times in total.)
Shave 4 - I attempted a 1st pass atg with the razor and called it quits after a few strokes. It didn't go well but I don't hold that against the razor. I did finish the shave up with 2 wtg passes and I did feel a bit more blade feel. I think this had to do with the fact that this was the first time I did a shave around the 24 hour mark vs my others which were around 48  hours.

Final Thoughts

Pros -  

Plug-in-play - I like that this razor is completely functional to me as it comes. It's already polished and the handle is not too heavy. With my Overlander I had to hand polish to top cap to reduce drag and I'm using a titanium handle because the 90mm one that came with it is too heavy. The razor is also perfectly balanced.

Efficiency - this has been the most efficient razor I have used in a long while...perhaps ever. I have used a lot of more aggressive razors but I have never really noticed any increased efficiency.... Certainly not any that would justify the aggression. The comfort to efficiency ratio is just superb.

ATG - this one of 3 razors of the 40 I have used that I can go atg with comfortably. This is probably the most important factor to me and it is impressive.

Blade tabs are covered - that's how I roll. 

Cons - 

Aggression - I barely noticed this when I was waiting 48 hours between shaves but when compared to my Overlander, there is a slight increase in blade feel. This was more noticeable when I did a shave with it at ~24 hours. If you have super sensitive skin, you may not enjoy this. I would say this was at the upper threshold of what I was willing to tolerate as I like as minimal of blade feel as possible.

Handle - as much as I liked the light weight I prefer more grip. 

Titanium - this is a double-edged sword. I love the weight and balance but don't like the increased price and scratches. Honestly, I think stainless steel would be my choice and preferably at a lower price. If I found the handle too heavy, I have a few titanium ones in the collection that I could use - no biggy. 

Blade Rigidity - I honestly felt (what I would call) "chatter or vibration" with this razor and I felt it on every shave. I didn't notice an increase in aftershave burn, tugging, or irritation but it was just very annoying. I just didn't like the feel of it. When comparing the blade support and blade reveal of the Overlander vs. the Diamondack - the Overlander won in both categories. I don't know if this is a subjective preference or what, but I just don't like that feeling and I wish there could be a v2 or extra rigid version of this razor that had both an extended baseplate support and extended top cap to reduce blade reveal. I would take the trade off in less lather slots any day of the week. I'll post some pics to illustrate this.

Aesthetics - this is completely subjective and doesn't really play a roll in much but it is not as attractive to me as my basic polished Wolfman WR2 with WRH1 handle. It is, however, on par to the Overlander to my eye!

---------------------------------------

Overall - Given the fact I have some razors already that I really like and have been trying to downsize - this is tough. I think that this is where I stand. I went to website to see about the pre-order and it was sold out - ha! Classic! I suppose that makes my life a bit easier. At the regular price, I would probably be a pass. At the pre-order price, I would be "seriously considering" it. If this was stainless steel (preferably 316L), I would be  "probably buying it." If it was stainless steel and a little more rigid, I would definitely be buying it.

Thanks to dtownvino  and Paradigm for this passaround. It was an epic one. Definitely within the top 2 or top 3 in my collection!

dtownvino, SinCityAg, Latherati and 5 others like this post
#114
(This post was last modified: 09-04-2024, 11:04 PM by Cutty Sharp. Edited 1 time in total.)
Just to illustrate blade rigidity - I am assuming these two factors play a roll in this but I suppose its anyone's guess.

You can see that Overlander (right) has 4 tabs that extend past where the Diamondback's support is. Please note however, the two center tabs are doing all the work as the two outer tabs miss clamping the blade that far out. That being said, it seems to work adequately, although I wish all 4 clamped the blade.
[Image: T66BQnx.jpeg]


With regards to blade reveal, you can also see that the Overlander top cap extends further revealing less blade as well. This is not the best picture set as the angles for both are a little off and not the same. The focus is also a little blurry. However, you can get the idea if you look at the amount of blade you can see. I think the bottom part of the inside-facing blades are the clearest.


[Image: zcALWlT.jpeg]

dtownvino, Lesser, Calm_Shaver and 3 others like this post
#115

Member
Chester County, PA
[Image: SOMyAfd.jpeg]

Great shave today, smooth and efficient… Two pass glass!

cigarman, Latherati, Cutty Sharp and 5 others like this post
#116
(09-06-2024, 12:27 PM)dtownvino Wrote: [Image: SOMyAfd.jpeg]

Great shave today, smooth and efficient… Two pass glass!

TPG FTW!

SinCityAg likes this post
#117

Member
Las Vegas
(This post was last modified: Yesterday, 06:00 AM by SinCityAg. Edited 1 time in total.)
The razor arrived today.  As noted by others, it is gorgeous!!!  Cutty Sharp did an outstanding job cleaning it.   He even provided a washer—thank you!  In terms of build quality, it is top-drawer.  I can definitely tell it is an elite razor by simply holding and admiring it.  Thank you dtownvino for allowing me the opportunity to try it.  

My first shave will be in the morning.  But tonight, I drink bourbon!!

[Image: hmOdMkb.jpeg]

Cutty Sharp, dtownvino, Shaving Panda and 4 others like this post
#118
(Yesterday, 05:59 AM)SinCityAg Wrote: The razor arrived today.  As noted by others, it is gorgeous!!!  Cutty Sharp did an outstanding job cleaning it.   He even provided a washer—thank you!  In terms of build quality, it is top-drawer.  I can definitely tell it is an elite razor by simply holding and admiring it.  Thank you dtownvino for allowing me the opportunity to try it.  

My first shave will be in the morning.  But tonight, I drink bourbon!!

[Image: hmOdMkb.jpeg]

Glad it arrived safe! Enjoy!

Dave in KY, SinCityAg, Calm_Shaver and 1 others like this post


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)