Let's make it tougher, Top Soap Brand

JabonMan but I would miss B&M terribly

Barrister & Mann

Saponificio Varesino

Currently Mystic Waters, CRSW not far behind.

Put me in the Stirling camp. Great value, I love the performance, their scent selection is nicely varied, and they produce the top 2, and 3 of my top 5 scents (Sharp Dressed Man, Executive Man, and Barbershop).

Barrister & Mann ... based on one soap - Leviathan. I think it's that good. Looking forward to trying Roam very soon

While B&M tops my list, Tiki Bar gets the most play - I own The Captain, Windy City, North Shore, 50's Dive Bar, Grand Cru and Volcano - all great scents and quality products (vegan and tallow).

Mystic Water or B&M, or Mystic Water or B...

For me it comes down to Mystic Water, CRSW, and Caties. I really do like B&M but the scents (other than Leviathon) just haven't wowed me and yeah I know I'm in the minority on that one.

Of the first three it's awefully hard to choose. I will have to get back to ya on this one!

Probably Czech & Speake.
Not only are the soaps excellent, but some of my favourite colognes/EdPs come from them.

Barrister & Mann ... based on one soap - Leviathan.  I think it's that good.  Looking forward to trying Roam very soon

While B&M tops my list, Tiki Bar gets the most play - I own The Captain, Windy City, North Shore, 50's Dive Bar, Grand Cru and Volcano - all great scents and quality products (vegan and tallow).

I agree with you on Leviathan. I think I could use that every day until it runs out, but then I would miss Lavanille, Night Music, Vanille......I'll stop there.