Haslinger recommendations please

Coconut is my favorite but with autumn coming Schafmilch is great too. It's smells like, well, soap. Amazing performer.

They all preform identically to me. I can't tell the difference in post shave feel or Slickness.

Coconut is my favorite.

Aloe smells okay. Based on ingredients the one with sheep milk and lanolin sounds most appealing to me. I can add my own scent to the lather.

I don't know if any scents would be nice when added to "Schafmilch", it has one of the stronger scents in the line. I mix Honey and Coconut Haslinger, but have never added any EO or scents to any.

They all preform identically to me.  I can't tell the difference in post shave feel or Slickness.

+1

They all preform identically to me.  I can't tell the difference in post shave feel or Slickness.

+1

I would have guessed the one with lanolin would be the favorite of most. Perhaps there's not enough in it to notice.

They all preform identically to me.  I can't tell the difference in post shave feel or Slickness.

+1

I would have guessed the one with lanolin would be the favorite of most. Perhaps there's not enough in it to notice.

The majority of guys who have used a few pucks, can't tell the difference. It must not contain much or maybe "Lanolin" belongs in the "myth thread".

I can't tell a difference which is why there so good. Stable product.

I think there was someone who added menthol crystals to the Schafmilch. That sounded cool.

I think there was someone who added menthol crystals to the Schafmilch. That sounded cool.

Pun intended I hope!

I don't agree that the Schafmilch smells like soap (unless it's a scented soap). I can easily detect a pleasant cologne-like fragrance. It's not a strong scent, but certainly present.

I've never tried it but it's on my list. I noticed on Maggards site that there are two sandalwood scents one is the SPA line. Per Maggards:

The Haslinger “SPA” line is a heavily scented sandalwood scent with a bolder, cologne-like scent.

Anyone try both and if so did you like one better than the other.  This is the only scent on the site with a SPA version.

Any of them. Seriously. Great soap; I'm especially fond of the Schafmilch (sheep's milk in German). They're small pucks, but that's okay.

It's like Mitchell's Wool Fat but easier to lather for those having trouble with that. Also a different scent for those that object to The Fat as well.