DR Harris, CF or AOS?

If you could only choose one citrusy based shaving cream between these companies, which would it be?

DRH Arlington, CF Lime, or AOS Lemon?

CF. No doubt about it.

For me, DRH for performance, CF for scent.

Those three are such great performers and similarly priced. The thing that makes me lean towards D. R. Harris is that you can get matching aftershave and cologne.

If the Arlington cream smelled like the soap does, that would be my choice. But it doesn't, so it's not.
While I like CF Lime, enough people have bad reviews of the scent to say it's iffy.
AOS Lemon smells like lemon. If that's what you want then that's your best bet. And AOS is every bit as good as or better than the others, with less fanboyism which is another plus in my mind.

D.R. Harris Arlington. Because I think Castle Forbes Lime smells like Lestoil.

D.R. Harris Arlington for me

I own all of them.

Performance: Castle Forbes, not even close
Scent: DR Harris

The AOS is still also very good, but I place it third here.

So everyone who favors Arlington's scent likes the fragrance better from the puck versus the cream?

So everyone who favors Arlington's scent likes the fragrance better from the puck versus the cream?

No, I own both and enjoy scents equally from cream as well as soap.