Aftershave balm sans alcohol/menthol

If you can kindly recommend some balms designed for sensitive skin I would greatly appreciate it, needless to say menthol and alcohol are forbidden for my skin type!  

Yes Jeff, I must agree with you on that. For me though, I found that it could use some improvements on both the scent strength front and the moisturizing and healing front as well. I have heard that reef point has great balms, too bad they contain menthol though!

For starters Thayers Witch Hazel is a must. Lucky Tiger is also very soothing with a mild orange scent. PAA also has some very nice non-alcohol based aftershave splashes.

The CRSW post shave lotions and the B&M Kyovu and Latha alcohol free splashes are great. However, the Kyovu is currently being reformulated. Also the B&M Latha Le Petit Chypre and CRSW Limenthol have menthol in the splashes as well.

Soap Commander balms are great and they offer Integrity menthol free.

I forgot to mention that Stirling Soap also has some really nice balms as well.