(This post was last modified: 07-03-2020, 02:48 PM by Ols67.)
Gents,
I have been having some fun testing different finishers, and I have out the Zulu Grey, Purple Welsh, Arkansas Tanslucent, Arkansas Black, and the Charnley Forest through their paces. Out of the pile of rocks, the Charnley Forest was my favorite finisher. However, something told me that I should continue the search.
I decided I get a JNAT Nakayama something or other, but BBS Kirk sang the Ancient Ocean Jasper high praises. I had heard good things about it before, and instead of going with a tried and true Nakayama JNAT...I went with a “translucent” Ancient Ocean Jasper. That is what Gabe, the proprietor, of Wild Whetstones calls it, but it is really just brown butterscotch/grey in color. This is a translucent Arkansas stone....
My 8x3x1 Butterscotch Ancient Ocean Jasper...not translucent!
However, it is a good looking stone, so no real complaint!
This is the hardest stone I have ever lapped, and it took me just over five hours with a nano plate and a DMT 325. If you get one I highly recommend using a glass plate with SIC powder, and starting off with the 60-100 range, and then working up from there.
Once it was lapped flat on one side, I ran my Brian Brown beater razor on it for 50 laps. This razor was freshly honed, and the bevel near the edge was a nice evenly consistent frosted/glazed/hazy appearance near the edge. After 50 laps with just water on the stone a mirror appeared on the bevel near the edge...I did another 50 light laps, and the mirror on the bevel near the edge became even more refined. I was floored, and pleasantly surprised to get this from a natural rock. I looked at this under a 10x loupe, and the edge was pristine and was passing the HHT all along the cutting surface. I thought to myself... “Yeah it’s a pretty novelty, but will it shave well?”
So I shaved with it, and again...I was floored. The shave was impeccable, and the edge felt like the perfect balance between sharp and smooth for my face. It was better than the Charnley Forest edges that I had been getting. The usual descriptors apply...butter...silky smooth...etc!
So I had a bunch of razors that I ran through a progression of natural stones, and I started putting the same jasper edge on them....mirror after mirror, and I can’t wait to use all six of them.
Yesterday, I received a Zwillingswerk 14 in the mail that has been in use for the last 85+ years and it shows. I suspect someone damaged the tip, and had the front ground down since it measures about 2.9 long, where my NOS Z14 is over three inches long. However, it had a nice bevel, nice hollow grind, and a straight spine...it also is just under 7/8 wide.
One of the things that the seller claims is that the Ancient Ocean Jasper replaces all stones after your bevel setter, including your finisher.
I like using a multi stone progression, and again...I was skeptical, and so I tried it with the beater Z14. I killed the edge, did some light bevel work on a Chosera 1k, then went to the Ancient Ocean Jasper...I slurried it, honed, slurried it again, honed, and continued to dilute with water from my spray bottle until i was just honing on the stone with water. At that point I tested to see how it would do on arm hair, and the hair simply was wiped off my arm. Then I honed on the jasper under a light and steady stream of water coming down in the middle of the stone. I did this for just a few minutes until the razor was sucking down onto the stone, and I was really feeling the stiction. At that point I Knew it was done, inspected the bevel near the edge with my eye, and it was a mirror...I looked under a 10x loupe, and it was beautiful! I stropped, and shaved. I was again floored...it behaved exactly as Gabe said it would, and the resultant edge was fantastic, and the shave even better.
In conclusion, my search for the ultimate finisher is over, and I don’t think I am going to bother going down the thuringian and JNAT rabbit holes. I am 100% happy with the edges that I am getting from the Ancient Ocean Jasper!
My wallet can stop its crying!
Has anyone else had a lot of experience with these stones? If so, how was it for you?
Thanks!
Vr
Matt
I have been having some fun testing different finishers, and I have out the Zulu Grey, Purple Welsh, Arkansas Tanslucent, Arkansas Black, and the Charnley Forest through their paces. Out of the pile of rocks, the Charnley Forest was my favorite finisher. However, something told me that I should continue the search.
I decided I get a JNAT Nakayama something or other, but BBS Kirk sang the Ancient Ocean Jasper high praises. I had heard good things about it before, and instead of going with a tried and true Nakayama JNAT...I went with a “translucent” Ancient Ocean Jasper. That is what Gabe, the proprietor, of Wild Whetstones calls it, but it is really just brown butterscotch/grey in color. This is a translucent Arkansas stone....
My 8x3x1 Butterscotch Ancient Ocean Jasper...not translucent!
However, it is a good looking stone, so no real complaint!
This is the hardest stone I have ever lapped, and it took me just over five hours with a nano plate and a DMT 325. If you get one I highly recommend using a glass plate with SIC powder, and starting off with the 60-100 range, and then working up from there.
Once it was lapped flat on one side, I ran my Brian Brown beater razor on it for 50 laps. This razor was freshly honed, and the bevel near the edge was a nice evenly consistent frosted/glazed/hazy appearance near the edge. After 50 laps with just water on the stone a mirror appeared on the bevel near the edge...I did another 50 light laps, and the mirror on the bevel near the edge became even more refined. I was floored, and pleasantly surprised to get this from a natural rock. I looked at this under a 10x loupe, and the edge was pristine and was passing the HHT all along the cutting surface. I thought to myself... “Yeah it’s a pretty novelty, but will it shave well?”
So I shaved with it, and again...I was floored. The shave was impeccable, and the edge felt like the perfect balance between sharp and smooth for my face. It was better than the Charnley Forest edges that I had been getting. The usual descriptors apply...butter...silky smooth...etc!
So I had a bunch of razors that I ran through a progression of natural stones, and I started putting the same jasper edge on them....mirror after mirror, and I can’t wait to use all six of them.
Yesterday, I received a Zwillingswerk 14 in the mail that has been in use for the last 85+ years and it shows. I suspect someone damaged the tip, and had the front ground down since it measures about 2.9 long, where my NOS Z14 is over three inches long. However, it had a nice bevel, nice hollow grind, and a straight spine...it also is just under 7/8 wide.
One of the things that the seller claims is that the Ancient Ocean Jasper replaces all stones after your bevel setter, including your finisher.
I like using a multi stone progression, and again...I was skeptical, and so I tried it with the beater Z14. I killed the edge, did some light bevel work on a Chosera 1k, then went to the Ancient Ocean Jasper...I slurried it, honed, slurried it again, honed, and continued to dilute with water from my spray bottle until i was just honing on the stone with water. At that point I tested to see how it would do on arm hair, and the hair simply was wiped off my arm. Then I honed on the jasper under a light and steady stream of water coming down in the middle of the stone. I did this for just a few minutes until the razor was sucking down onto the stone, and I was really feeling the stiction. At that point I Knew it was done, inspected the bevel near the edge with my eye, and it was a mirror...I looked under a 10x loupe, and it was beautiful! I stropped, and shaved. I was again floored...it behaved exactly as Gabe said it would, and the resultant edge was fantastic, and the shave even better.
In conclusion, my search for the ultimate finisher is over, and I don’t think I am going to bother going down the thuringian and JNAT rabbit holes. I am 100% happy with the edges that I am getting from the Ancient Ocean Jasper!
My wallet can stop its crying!
Has anyone else had a lot of experience with these stones? If so, how was it for you?
Thanks!
Vr
Matt