I must once again apologize for the lateness of this review. Life has been coming at me fast the last 4 months, with no indications of a slowdown.
I want to start by saying that I really appreciate
DanLaw organizing these passarounds of the H&S razors. At this point, I have been able to try out all of the different material versions of the P076. I am going to copy some snippets from my most recent Cu P076 review, as I believe it will give context, and my experience this time was fairly similar.
A little background on my recent shaving habits and my skin. I received my Wolfman WR2 1.15 SB back in mid-May, and I’ve been using it almost exclusively since then. I shave every other day. It took a couple of weeks for me to dial it in, but now I’m getting pretty smooth/efficient shaves. I have been wetshaving with a DE for about two and a half years, so I would consider myself pretty new at this. I have in that time tried out quite a few razors, and so far my preferences lean to mild/mid aggressive. I *think* that I have somewhat sensitive skin, as I’m typically only able to shave every other day without getting a decent amount of irritation after a few days.
Wholly Kaw soaps:
I have tried a few samples of WK in the Siero base prior to this, and these performed the same as those samples. The WK scents that I have encountered have not been my favorites. Of these two, I would say my preference leaned towards Vor V, although I go back and forth on whether I really like it or not… one day I would sniff and really be impressed, another it would just not tickle my fancy. Valentynka is definitely not one I would purchase.
Performance-wise, the Siero base is upper tier. It is a great base, but for me doesn’t quite perform as well as a few others that I use regularly. That’s not to take away from the high-level of this soap base, though… it is definitely top notch.
Wholly Kaw cream:
The Dulci Tobacco cream that was included with this pass around is unlike any cream that I have used. Updating the packaging from this pre-production container was a good move, as the cream seemed to have melted a bit in the hot southern Alabama weather. I had to scrape a large portion off the inside of the lid, and replace it into the container. The scent is very sweet to me, and I had a hard time picking up the tobacco. Maybe this is more tobacco flower? I left the lid off for a couple of days as Dan had suggested, but still got a mostly sweet scent with just a hint of tobacco. That’s not to say that I didn’t like the scent, as this was by far my favorite of the three. Performance-wise for me, the cream did not match the soaps. I had a hard time getting a good lather with the cream, and it just wasn’t as slick for me as the soaps. This could easily be user error, as I’m not nearly as used to lathering creams these days.
Wholly Kaw AS, Balm, and Toner:
The AS that paired with the Vor V soap had a nice scent, and as Dan pointed out, a little bit more fruity note. The AS performance was very good, up there with other top end after shaves. I used the Bare Naked balm on a couple of the shaves where I experienced some irritation. It did a good job of calming the irritation, but most balms are just not for me. I have VERY oily skin, and almost every balm that I’ve ever tried adds to that issue rather than helping with it. This balm was no different. I believe it would work well for anyone with dry to normal skin. The toner, on the other hand, is the star of these three products. I actually prefer a toner to most aftershaves (Ethos Skin Food Splash being the exception.) Lucky Tiger is the toner that I use often, and the Bare Naked toner from WK performs as well or better.
The razor:
This 316 SS P076 is a more utilitarian design aesthetic than the other P076 models that were passed around, and I like it. That’s not to say that I didn’t like the others, but there’s something about the simplicity of this handle design that is very appealing to me. I much prefer longer handles, and this one is a good length for me. The knurling on the handle is fairly aggressive, it actually reminds me of knurling on an Olympic weightlifting bar. (It could be toned down a bit, although it was fine with me during use). The head is that same beautifully polished, perfect fit and finish that I now expect from H&S. The packaging from H&S is also very impressive, much better than I’ve seen from other high-end razors.
I only used the SB side (don’t typically get along at all with OC), I used a couple of different blades (Nacet, Wizamet), and got fairly similar results with all three. This handle design does change the handling a bit, and also the shave experience to a certain degree. This razor is very efficient. Much like the copper version, I was able to get ok shaves, but in the end they were all a little bit harsh. I do think I got slightly better shaves with the 316 than with the Cu. That said, the ATG passes were definitely not as smooth as I would like, and I ended up with a bit of irritation on all of my shaves, although not as many weepers as with the Cu. This could possibly be attributed to me just getting a little better with technique required for the P076. I just can’t seem to get along with the positive blade exposure of this razor. As I stated, I’m fairly new to DE shaving in the grand scheme of things. I do have razors that I’ve cracked the code for me to use, but there have been quite a few (P076 being one) that I haven’t been able to use.
This is a great razor, and will give many individuals great shaves. I did get some good shaves when I tried the 17-4 version, so maybe the stars aligned and I hit the technique just right, or maybe that material works better for me. I don’t know that I’ll ever find out, though, as I’m not likely to spend the $$ to get one to continue the testing.
Thanks again to
DanLaw and Wholly Kaw for this pass around!