To me it seems that the razor hasn't created the amount of buzz that was expected. I mean, when they first showed their General series of razors, the interest in acquiring one of those just skyrocketed especially in the Brass and Stainless alloys. Even more so when the reports started coming in that it was a mild, smooth yet efficient shavers. They were different and just hit the right spot on RAD glands. And the Silversmith could potentially be the same way once it's in the hands of razor enthusiasts.
The Silversmith is somewhere in the middle, at least for me it is. I don't hate the look but, I don't love it either. Even though it's being made of a premium alloy with actually a pretty good price point, it doesn't jump at me and make me say "I need that in my rotation" as I would usually get when I see a new razor potentially being released. Maybe I'm just not into 18th century inspired design that it comes from. From what has been said and stated on their website is it's a middle of the road shaver in terms of mild/aggressive blade feel. And that's fine as there is no harm in that. But, there are plenty of razors out there that are middle of the road that to me just look aesthetically better.
In the end, the two brothers at Colonial seem like real good guys and I wish them real success on this one. What I'm really looking forward to is the 2nd Gen. General. That one has me chasing....