Bay Rum Similarities

Yeah, I only had a sample of their bay rum early on in my wetshaving journey. I didn't know what bay rum was so naturally, I was curious. That's why samples are the way to go if you're not sure.

Careful with Stirling's Bay Rum aftershave. It's got some burn to it! Don't get it if you don't like clove-y bay rums.

That's actually a part of the problem...i honestly don't know if i like a clove-y bay rum

Maybe I'll start with a sample the next time i order some bath soap. They also have a Bay Rum Witch Hazel, which I assume will be very similar to the AS.

I can't use Stirling's Bay Rum splash. It is extremely warm in my opinion.

I routinely follow Captains Choice Bay Rum with Captains Choice Cat o Nine Tails splash in the winter and I simply LOVE the burn.

Stirling's Bay Rump Splash brought tears to my eyes. I used it once and ended up washing my head to get it off. Even after the dry down it continued to burn. I ended up tossing the rest of the sample out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I'm not sure I understand the question - choosing between bay rums? Just get them all. Seriously though, many (most) bay rums have more similarities than differences with only a few deviating significantly from the profile.

I'm not sure I understand the question - choosing between bay rums?  Just get them all.  Seriously though, many (most) bay rums have more similarities than differences with only a few deviating significantly from the profile.

I agree..most of them are somewhat similar with minor differences.

Another vote for Krampert's! Great scent and skincare, not much burn if the shave was good.